A New Masculine Paradigm
I’ve noticed something over the last five years. Every week I am talking to more and more dads. More fathers are reaching out for sleep help and today I would say that for initial phone conversations 90% of the time dad is on the call with mom.
Some Stats on American Dads
- More dads are staying home to care for their kids.
- Dads see parenting as central to their identity.
- Work-family balance is a challenge for many working fathers.
- Most Americans think men face a lot of pressure to provide financially for their family.
- It’s become less common for dads to be their family’s sole breadwinner.
I’ve noticed all of these in my practice coupled with a deep desire in men to be the best fathers and partners they can be. These last three inspired me to write this post.
6. Dads are much more involved in child care than they were 50 years ago.
7. While they’re spending more time with their children, many dads feel they’re not doing enough.
8. When it comes to caregiving, moms and dads are still viewed differently.
In an effort to be more involved with their children, more fathers are choosing work that offers flexible hours and that they can do from home. And just like moms, they still don’t feel like they are doing enough. The number of “stay at home dads” who are primary caregivers has doubled over the last ten years. Yet in the Pew Research Center study the researchers found that there is still a significant bias that father does not know best. Stay at home moms were still more favorably looked upon as the better primary care giver.
The public is largely supportive of the idea of mothers staying at home with their children, but they place less value on having a stay-at-home father. In a 2013 Pew Research Center survey, fully 51% of respondents said children are better off if their mother is home and doesn’t hold a job. By comparison, only 8% said children are better off if their father is home and doesn’t work.
My response to this was – WTF?
When working with fathers and their families here is what I notice.
- Fathers are desperately trying to support their wives with getting better sleep and are deeply concerned about her wellbeing in general. For one, they are smart. Men know that we are nicer to them when we are well rested. Two, we tend to be more affectionate when we don’t have another human being hanging off of our breasts 24/7.
- Dads tend to NOT be as enmeshed with their children and are better at boundaries, autonomy and loving limits. Makes since when I look at the chemical brain difference of men and women and the interaction of testosterone and oxytocin.
- Our children tend to sleep better for dads than moms. There are many factors that contribute to this general observational fact but the main one is this; by eight weeks of age your smart, scientific brained baby knows that dad is never going to sprout a breast and spontaneously start to feed her.
This generation of women are the beneficiaries of this new paradigm of the masculine in our culture and in our homes. But have we adjusted our ever changing feminine to this changing masculine? As a Transformational Mediator here is what I have also noticed, where there are great advantages to this change in the family structure, there are also new challenges.
Can the still fairly new feminine paradigm support our men in these changes and challenges?
Personally, I think we need a major overhaul of the feminine paradigm as well but I will save that for another blog post.
I often see a resistance to – letting go and letting dad. As in, COMPLETELY letting go. When I say completely I mean to let go and let dad soothe and reassure the babies even when this happens …
Do we hold the conceit that we are the superior child soother and more intuitive care giver? When dad steps in to facilitate sleep or night weaning do we go masculine and rip the baby from his arms? Does dad counter step into his feminine, step down and hand over the baby?
Neither way is right or wrong. Both are just a reality of our humanness. The approach I teach offers both the feminine and masculine response. But as adults we need to know what and when either is called for. Our children need both, because every human has both feminine and masculine qualities and abilities. Even two mothers raising children will offer both feminine and masculine qualities to their family’s care and nurturing. So this isn’t a gender issue or a “sex roles” issue. Perhaps the new paradigm of the masculine and feminine will include the integration of these polar opposite energies.
The masculine is about structure, form, mastery and stepping up to “do something”. Men are very much about service and will take charge and do what is in the best interest of his woman and his family. We women both love and complain about our man’s desire and assertiveness to come to solutions and “fix it”. The feminine is about receiving and allowing. We are about the formless and the mystery. And we too are willing to do what is in the best interest of our family. However, we naturally go about it differently.
My invitation is to become mindful of how we do these aspects of the self. This takes introspection and accountability. And that takes courage, humility and vulnerability. We ask ourselves the following questions as individuals first and as partnered parents second.
- When we come to our differences in the middle of the night, exhausted, emotional and uncertain, and we meet our partner in disagreement on how this all should be handled, how do we navigate this dance of the feminine and masculine?
- How do we support one another in this difficult and relentless task of parenting our children?
- Do we listen and empathize with each other’s perspective?
- Can we see their perspective and their intention to be helpful and supportive?
- Can we recognize when the more feminine approach (mending, tending and holding) is called for?
- Can we recognize when the more masculine approach (separateness, autonomy, limits and boundaries) is called for?